A Dog, a Cow and a Cyclist Ride into a Bar

       People get injured and they look to blame someone and if that someone has an insurance policy, a lawyer may be there to help.  Not every injury is awarded compensation.  For instance if you trip over a inch difference in the grade of a sidewalk, the courts will not likely award you anything. 

       What happens if you let you cow roam around the neighborhood?   In 2013 in a decision by the Court of Appealsin Albany, the highest court in the State, a woman was allowed to sue the owner of a cow she crashed into with her van. 
Sounded like the Court of Appeals felt people have to keep their animals on a leash or be liable for mishaps.  Or so that it is what two lower courts ruled.   The names of those cases were  Doerr v. Goldsmith and Dobinski v. Lockhart. The cases involved Wolfgang Doerr, who was injured in 2009 after crashing into a 45-pound shepherd mix on Central Park’s bicycle loop road, and Cheryl Dobinski, who fell from her bike in 2012 when she tried to avoid two German shepherds that ran onto the road near their rural home south of Buffalo.  In the New York City  case the lower court awarded significant damages to a cyclist who collided with a dog.  After a trial  the jury awarded the plaintiff $1,000,000.  On appeal the next highest court reduced that to $600,000.  I can only assume there was an insurance company funding the defense because this case was taken to the Court of Appeals.
 
       Just this June that Court ruled a cyclist cannot sue a dog’s owners, saying riders should be careful not to cross paths with animals that are a constant public presence.  To distinguish this decision from the 2013 cow case Judge Sheila Abdus-Salaam wrote, “In public parks, one regularly encounters dog owners with their unrestrained canine companions … whereas one ... certainly never expects to see someone taking his or her cow for a walk in the neighborhood.”  The court said the cyclists could not sue the dog owners because they had not shown that the dogs had a history of biting or attacking people.  A lower appeals court cited the cow case when it revived Doerr’s lawsuit, but the Court of Appeals last week  reversed the decision.

      I like this decision.  Dogs running after bikes is something I grew up with, it is common and that is just life.  Oh yea this has nothing to do with a bar, but I did think an award of $1,000,000 to the Central Park cyclist was a joke.



Alexander Novak, 

Partner, Novak Juhase & Stern

Check us out on Facebook, LinkedIn, and at njslaw.com

Grandparents Have No Automatic Rights To Visitation

      In many of our families, grandparents play a special role in the lives of our children.  They are the source of free babysitting and frequently they are intimately involved in our children’s lives.  But what happens when there is discord between grandparents and their children and they are prevented from seeing their grandchildren?  Do they automatically have a right of visitation. The answer in New York is no.  If the parents refuse visitation, a grandparent must go to court and he may not win.

      Under N.Y. law, a grandparent’s right to petition for visitation is restricted to only two circumstances. When either parent of the grandchild has died, a grandparent has an absolute right to petition.  If both parents are living, a grandparent has standing to request visitation rights only if he can establish circumstances in which equity would see fit to intervene.  This means that the grandparent has to show that he has maintained a close and long term existing relationship with the child or tried to do so and was prevented by the parent.  Where contact has been sporadic or just involved sending birthday and holiday cards, the court will not grant the petition.  Allegations of love and affection are not enough.

     Even if a grandparent has standing to petition for visitation, he still has to show that visitation is in the best interests of the child.  Where both parents who are still married to each other strongly object to the grandparent’s visitation, it will probably be denied.  The N.Y. Court of Appeals (Article by the New York Sun) has held that there is a strong presumption that the parents’ wishes governs regarding the best interests of the child and this creates a high hurdle for petitioning grandparents to overcome.

      If, as a grandparent, you foresee possible visitation problems in the future, you should try to be involved in your grandchild’s life as much as is reasonable.  If the parents try to restrict your contact, you should document you attempts to do so.

Kim Steven Juhase, ESQ.

Partner, Novak Juhase & Stern

Check us out on Facebook, LinkedIn, and at njslaw.com